ATCOR De-Hazing Algorithm - Some Limitations

There are several limitations to the haze reduction method. But these are due to the variety of nature and not of the algorithm (cloud types, variability on cloud coverage...). So the result depends very much on the input data. With one image it works fine and with the other it looks as if ATCOR doesn't change a thing... 

Also be aware that the haze reduction is an optional step for a real atmospheric correction. This -second step- also works without the prior haze reduction.   

The following lists the possible constraints and ways to determine if a image can be haze corrected with ATCOR:

Percentage of Haze in an image: The method needs hazy and clear areas within the image! If only limited clear areas are availa­ble (image has pre­domi­nantly haze and clouds) the algo­rithm fails (or might over-correct certain areas).

 

Type of ‘Clouds’: In the scien­tific paper* on which the algo­rithm is based the authors speak about "an image trans­form to cha­racter­ize and com­pen­sate for spatial vari­ations in thin cloud con­tami­nation...". Accordingly only thin clouds/haze can be reduced in its appearance [a good example for "haze" within an image can be seen here].

An a priori test if a hazy image area ("cloud") can be haze corrected is to check if the RED and NIR-bands (e.g. for IKONOS = bands 3,4) are tran­sparent (the ground can be seen). If YES, it is haze (in the sense of ATCOR = thin cloud con­tami­nation) which ATCOR can 'tackle' if NO, it is an im­permeable cloud and can not be haze corrected.

To test the above: display Bands 2, 3 and 4 without applying any stretch. If the background becomes visible everything is set for an ATCOR success.

Examples: 

In both images on the left (displayed in the 2xStDev Stretch) the cloud seems to have the same density. If displayed in band combination 4,3,2 as R,G,B without any histogram stretch it becomes obvious that in the example on the bottom ATCOR can not reduce the cloud cover much besides in a small transition zone.

If there is no good corre­lation bet­ween the blue and red band (r < 0.8) the method also fails to pro­duce good re­sults Info on the correlation coefficient 'r' [External Link].


The method can also be used for data without the blue band but will yield less per­fect re­sults by using the green band as a substitute. This is true for sen­sors like e.g. IRS.


The algo­rithm is not suitable for haze over water.


Originally the Haze Correction is an optional pre-processing step to the Athmospheric Correction only. While it can be run independently without the Atmospheric Correction, it has limitations (which the Atmospheric Correction does not have): Size constraint: an image can not have more than 8K * 8K in size

*Zhang, Y., Guindon, B., and Cihlar, J., "An image transform to characterize and compensate for spatial variations in thin cloud contamination of Landsat images", Remote Sensing of Environment, Vol. 82, 173-187 (2002).


You are here: > www.atcor.de > News > De-Hazing Limitations

 

Last Update: 06-05-11 

GEOSYSTEMS GmbH - Riesstrasse 10 - D-82110 Germering - Germany - e-Mail: geosystems@geosystems.de